Part 4 · Diagnosis & complications
The differential
A hot, swollen joint is not always gout: septic arthritis, CPP crystal arthritis and cellulitis can look the same, and infection can sit alongside crystals. Pick a clue to light up the conditions it points to, then sweep the joint-fluid white count to see how the odds of infection change.
- Fever, sweats or rigorsBut their absence does not exclude infection: fever had a sensitivity of only 57%. 248
- Prosthetic joint, diabetes, RA, skin infection or HIVEach is a risk factor for septic arthritis. 248
- A shoulderSeptic shoulders in crystal arthritis were bacteraemic in 90%. 305
- A ruptured or discharging tophusRuptured, infected tophi were the commonest route in 30 people with septic gout. 442
- An atypical pictureEULAR 2018 says atypical presentations should be investigated further. 332
Crystals do not exclude infection. Infection was found in 1.5% of 265 crystal-positive aspirates, and in 5% of crystal-positive joints in another series. 305,363 Coexistence is very unlikely only when the Gram stain is negative, CRP is under 100 mg/L and the joint white count is under 10,000/µL. 305
Side by side
A dash means the sources used here give no distinguishing feature for that cell. A trauma or fracture row is left out because no source was checked for it.
Joint fluid: how likely is infection?
Likelihood ratios are pooled from 14 studies (6,242 patients, 653 with septic arthritis). Each LR belongs to its own cut-off (above or below it), not to the band between two cut-offs. 248
CPP crystal arthritis: its own criteria
The 2023 ACR/EULAR CPPD criteria have an entry step (joint pain, swelling or tenderness), exclude cases fully explained by another disease, and classify at a score above 56. Sensitivity and specificity were 92.2%/87.9% in derivation and 99.2%/92.5% in validation. Crowned dens syndrome is a sufficient criterion. 2,3
When gout turns septic
In 30 people with septic gout, 30% had a normal blood count and 10% a joint count under 6,000/mm³. S. aureus caused 16 cases, and a third had no fever. 442 A 50,000/µL cut-off missed 39% of 49 culture-proven septic joints, and 55% had a negative Gram stain. 260
A gout score is not an infection test
Comparing 82 gout and 54 septic joints, the Janssens score averaged 8.6 vs 3.6 (AUC 0.933), but 3 of the 54 septic joints still scored "high". 226
Cellulitis and its mimics
Cellulitis has no effective diagnostic test, and an organism is identified in about 15%. 321 Of 259 people admitted with "lower-limb cellulitis", 30.5% had another diagnosis. 429
Rheumatoid and psoriatic arthritis
RA 2010: synovitis in at least 1 joint and a score of 6 or more of 10 from joint count, serology, acute-phase reactants and duration. 6 CASPAR: inflammatory joint disease plus 3 or more points (specificity 0.987, sensitivity 0.914). 399
Reactive arthritis
Acute oligoarthritis of larger joints, 2–4 weeks after a gut or urogenital infection, with an incidence of 0.6–27 per 100,000 a year. HLA-B27 is not a diagnostic test. 155