Part 4 · Crisis, care & the future
Myasthenic crisis
Myasthenic crisis is MG weakness severe enough to need help with breathing. Press play to follow a schematic 21-day course: the trigger, falling breathing numbers, BiPAP or intubation, plasma exchange or IVIG, and weaning. Then compare myasthenic and cholinergic crisis.
What counts as crisis. The international consensus defines manifest crisis as worsening severe enough to need intubation, or noninvasive ventilation to avoid intubation (MGFA class V, unless the intubation is routine after surgery). Impending crisis is rapid worsening that, in the treating physician's opinion, could lead to crisis within days to weeks. Crisis can come from weak breathing muscles or from bulbar weakness with collapse of the upper airway. 82,271,476
Who and when. About 15-20% of people with MG have at least one crisis; other reviews give 10-20%, or one-fifth to one-third of generalized MG. It usually happens in the first 2-3 years: median 8 months from first symptoms in one series. In about one-fifth, crisis is the first sign of MG. 75,82,254,512,547
1 · Three weeks of a crisis, schematic
Schematic: one illustrative course, not a real patient. The lines are modelled, not measured; their anchors are published: the thresholds, the onset times of plasma exchange (about 2 days) and IVIG (about 4-5 days), BiPAP results, and the share of people extubated by day 7, 13 and 31. The breath count is derived from the rule of thumb "count × 100 ≈ FVC in mL" for a 70 kg adult. Day 0 is the first worsening; intubation is placed on day 4.5. 113,486,511,512,547
2 · The breathing numbers
| Measure | MG studies and reviews | The "20/30/40" rule (Guillain-Barré, Lawn 2001) |
|---|---|---|
| Vital capacity | Ventilation unlikely above 20 mL/kg (42 people with severe MG). A review: under 1 L, or under 20-25 mL/kg, signals significant weakness. Lower VC before and at admission went with worse outcomes. 383,511,547 | Under 20 mL/kg 308 |
| Maximal inspiratory pressure (MIP, NIF) | Ventilation unlikely when more negative than −40 cmH2O; a fall of 30% or more marked higher risk. A review: weaker than −20 cmH2O signals significant weakness. 511,547 | Weaker than 30 cmH2O 308 |
| Maximal expiratory pressure (MEP) | Ventilation unlikely above 40 cmH2O; a review says below 40 may signal crisis. 511,547 | Under 40 cmH2O 308 |
| Fall over time | A small ICU series found repeated VC, even with 20 or 13 mL/kg cut-offs, did not separate episodes that needed ventilation, which the authors put down to MG's erratic course. 452 | A fall of more than 30% in any of the three 308 |
| Single breath count | Count aloud on one deep breath at 2 counts per second, seated: ≥25 fits normal breathing muscles; difficulty reaching 20 signals expiratory weakness. It correlated with FVC, NIF and neck flexor strength in 31 people with AChR MG. The MG Core Exam scores it 0 (≥30), 1 (25-29), 2 (20-24) or 3 (<20). 103,113,214,547 | Not part of the rule |
| Blood gases and oximetry | PaCO2 above 45 mmHg at BiPAP start was the only predictor of BiPAP failure (above 50 in an earlier series). Oxygen saturation can look normal while CO2 is high: 54% of one neuromuscular group with high CO2 had SpO2 ≥95%, in chronic (not acute) respiratory failure. 208,437,486 | Not part of the rule |
The 20/30/40 cut-offs come from 114 people with severe Guillain-Barré syndrome. A neuromuscular review notes the rule was proposed for that disease, and no MG-specific validation of the full rule was found in the sources read. No single tool predicts neuromuscular respiratory failure well; a combined, repeated bedside assessment is preferred. 308,342,534
3 · Plasma exchange or IVIG: where the sources disagree
Consensus Expert opinion
The 2016 international consensus: trials suggest the two work equally well in impending or manifest crisis, but "expert consensus suggests that PLEX is more effective and works more quickly". A 2023 review says plasmapheresis "is preferred", and a crisis-centre guideline favours PLEX. 82,270,476
Randomized trials RCTs
- 87 people in exacerbation: muscle score change at day 15 +18 with 3 PLEX vs +15.5 with IVIG; side effects in 8 vs 1. 184
- 84 with moderate-to-severe worsening: IVIG 1 g/kg/day × 2 as effective as 5 PLEX at day 14 (69% vs 65% improved). 34
- Meta-analysis: QMG difference −2.8 favouring PLEX, not significant, with a trend to faster effect in the first 2 weeks. 419
Crisis cohorts Observational
- 54 crises: PLEX gave better breathing at 2 weeks and function at 1 month, with more complications (13 vs 5). 436
- US inpatient data: similar outcomes, possible cost advantage for IVIG. 333
- Germany: PLEX or immunoadsorption first went with less invasive ventilation, and IVIG first with more weaning failure (OR 2.53); another German cohort found no difference. 383,384,385
Who gets which
The consensus ties the choice to the person: PLEX is avoided in sepsis, IVIG in hypercoagulable states, renal failure or immunoglobulin hypersensitivity. Regimens in one review: IVIG 400 mg/kg/day for 5 days, or 5 plasma exchanges over 10 days. Any regimen for a person is set by the treating clinician. 476,547
4 · Myasthenic or cholinergic crisis?
Cholinergic crisis is rare now. The consensus says cholinergic crises are now rare, though too much cholinesterase inhibitor cannot always be ruled out as a cause of worsening; one crisis series found no cholinergic cases at all. The pyridostigmine label says the two crises may be difficult to distinguish on symptoms, and that cholinergic crisis calls for prompt withdrawal of these drugs. 151,476,547
The old edrophonium test. The edrophonium (Enlon) label lists use for evaluating emergency treatment in myasthenic crises, with atropine 1 mg ready and a warning to watch a patient in crisis for bradycardia or cardiac standstill. The consensus documents read do not recommend the test in crisis; no guideline sentence saying "avoid" was found. 138,476
Tap the signs below. Each one drops into the column the sources point it to. The tilt only counts the taps: it is a study aid, not a way to tell the two crises apart.
Points to myasthenic (too little effect)
Points to cholinergic (too much drug)
Seen in both
Not in the sources read
Sources for each sign appear in the columns. Muscarinic signs (sweating, tearing, salivation, nausea, diarrhoea, slow heart) and fasciculations come from a crisis review and the edrophonium label. 138,547
5 · How long it lasts, and who stays longer
Group figures from one series of 73 crises (1983-1994), not a prediction for one person. Relative hazards: bicarbonate 4.5, VC 2.9, age 2.4. 512
Time on the ventilator
12 daysmedian in 250 ventilated German crises; 20.5% of survivors still needed ventilation at discharge. Mean 10.4 days at Mayo; median hospital stay 17 days for intubated patients in a review. 384,486,547
Tracheostomy
49.8%of ventilated crises had one. Ventilation lasted 34.4 days with tracheostomy vs 7.9 without, and early tracheostomy (by day 10) was linked to about 2 weeks less ventilation and ICU stay. 18
MuSK antibodies
43 vs 17 daysventilation in MuSK-only vs AChR crises (43.0 vs 17.4); ICU stay 45.3 vs 21.2 days. Severity at diagnosis, thymoma and MuSK antibodies independently predicted crisis or exacerbation in 815 patients; thymoma-associated MG reached crisis sooner. 253,299,383
Newer drugs in crisis Early evidence
- C5 inhibitors in 17 crises not responding to standard therapy: 82% left ICU/IMC within 6 weeks; 2 died of sepsis; no meningococcal infection. 193
- Emergency eculizumab, 5 episodes: QMG 28.2 to 15.0 within 48 h. 255
- Efgartigimod, 16 with impending crisis, no control arm: 75% met the MG-ADL endpoint at week 8; in 10 crises all were weaned. 492,501
Case series and single-arm studies only; no randomized trial in crisis was found. 193,492
6 · Deaths per crisis, then and now
All bars are published values. The cohorts differ: the German one was ventilated only and older (median age 72), which its authors called comparable to earlier reports given age and disease burden; in the Chinese cohort, all-cause mortality over about 29 months was 15.16%, mostly septic shock and multiorgan failure. A review gives 5-12%. At Columbia all deaths came from overwhelming medical illness. 16,84,254,384,512,534