Part 3 · Diagnosis
The differential
NMOSD, MOGAD, small-vessel disease, migraine and other conditions can look like MS. Watch MRI patterns morph from MS to NMOSD to MOGAD, then click red flags to see which mimics they point to.
MS is a diagnosis of exclusion: the criteria only apply when there is no better explanation 218. Across studies, 5%–41% of MS diagnoses were wrong; the pooled figure was 15% 512. A 2008 consensus scored 79 red flags (36 major, 32 intermediate, 11 minor), and a 2023 consensus updated them 315,442.
Three MRI patterns
Schematic composite, not real scans. Lesion lengths follow the published definitions (MS cord lesions under two segments; LETM at least three contiguous segments); positions and shapes are illustrative.
Red flags
Click a red flag. The conditions it points to are flagged in the table below, and the box explains why.
Conditions × features
"—" means the sources used here give no distinguishing feature for that column, not that there is none. Rows marked with an underline jump the animation to that pattern. Routine syphilis or HIV testing: no source read for this guide gives consensus wording, so none is stated.
How misdiagnosis happens
What people misdiagnosed with MS really had
110 patients at 4 US centres (Solomon 2016) 441:
70% had received a disease-modifying therapy, 31% had unnecessary morbidity, and 33% had carried the wrong diagnosis for 10 years or more 441.
Referrals to two Los Angeles centres
17% and 19% of referrals already carrying an MS diagnosis were misdiagnosed (Kaisey 2019). Commonest true diagnoses: migraine 16%, RIS 9%, spondylopathy 7%, neuropathy 7%. About 110 patient-years of unnecessary DMT had been given 228.
Early evidence In 2024, 21% (73 of 347) of referrals for suspected MS in London had other disorders, most often migraine or functional neurological disorder with non-specific or vascular white-matter lesions 54.
The three commonest errors
- Treating symptoms atypical for demyelination as attacks.
- Accepting attacks without objective evidence of a CNS lesion.
- Over-relying on MRI spots in people with non-specific symptoms 441.