Part 2 · Diagnosis & course
The differential: ALS mimics
Several conditions can look like ALS early on, and some of them are treatable. Press Play to walk the decision points doctors describe, then pick a condition to see where it branches off and which test separates it.
A teaching simplification of published reviews. Real work-ups run several of these checks at once and repeat them over time.
Conditions and features
Each row is a condition from the reviews read for this guide; the first row is ALS itself for reference. A dash means the feature is not described for that condition in those sources. Click a row, or use the buttons above, to show where the condition branches off in the tree.
| Condition | UMN signs | LMN signs | Sensory | Sphincters | Eye movements | Pace | Key test |
|---|
Also named in the same reviews: neuralgic amyotrophy (severe pain at onset, then arrest), Hirayama disease (young men, one-sided C7–T1 weakness, flexion MRI), adrenomyeloneuropathy (very-long-chain fatty acids), primary progressive MS (MRI, CSF bands), paraneoplastic syndromes and adult polyglucosan body disease. 194,202,502
Red flags for another diagnosis
- Prominent sensory featuresCopper deficiency, CIDP, Kennedy disease
- Sphincter, visual or autonomic disturbanceMyelopathy, HSP
- Basal ganglia signsParkinsonian syndromes, hexosaminidase A deficiency
- Abnormal eye movementsMyasthenia gravis
- Fluctuating or fatigable weaknessMyasthenia gravis
- Severe pain at onsetNeuralgic amyotrophy; brachial radiation plexopathy
- Conduction block or demyelinationMMN, CIDP
- Weakness out of proportion to wastingMMN
- No progression over timeBenign fasciculations, other slow mimics
Red flags as listed across the sources; the conditions under each are examples drawn from the table above. 133,194,202,413,502
How often the first diagnosis changes
Irish ALS Register
Of 437 referrals in 1993–1997, 32 were later rediagnosed. Multifocal motor neuropathy (7, 22%) and Kennedy disease (4, 13%) were the commonest. 84% of the mimics had met only the "suspected" or "possible" El Escorial levels, 13% "probable" and 3% "definite". 497
Scottish MND Register
Of 552 people registered, 46 had another diagnosis, and a potentially beneficial treatment existed for half of them. Failure to progress, atypical features or test results prompted the revision. 133
Across population studies
Nearly 10% of people diagnosed with ALS turn out to have another condition, and a few conditions account for most of these. No register figure more recent than these two was found for this guide. 202,502